Book Review: Bartleby, the Scrivener by Herman Melville By: Nishanth Balaji

 

Book Review: Bartleby, the Scrivener by Herman Melville

By: Nishanth Balaji

Herman Melville’s Bartleby, the Scrivener is a compelling exploration of isolation, resistance, and the dehumanizing effects of modern capitalism. First published in 1853, this novella presents the enigmatic figure of Bartleby, a law-copyist who famously declines tasks with the phrase, “I would prefer not to.” Through Bartleby’s passive resistance, Melville examines themes of individuality, societal expectations, and the complexities of human connection.

Isolation and Passive Resistance

At its core, Bartleby, the Scrivener is a study of isolation. Bartleby’s withdrawal from the world, both physically and emotionally, highlights the alienation inherent in modern workspaces. His refusal to perform tasks becomes a form of quiet rebellion, challenging the narrator’s expectations and the norms of a productivity-driven society.

Bartleby’s enigmatic behavior—neither overtly confrontational nor entirely submissive—forces readers to grapple with the meaning of resistance. His refrain, “I would prefer not to,” embodies a quiet but profound rejection of societal pressures, inviting reflection on the limits of individual agency within rigid systems.

The Dehumanizing Effects of Capitalism

Melville critiques the dehumanizing nature of capitalism through Bartleby’s relationship with his work. As a scrivener, Bartleby’s role is monotonous and devoid of creative fulfillment, reducing him to a mere cog in the machinery of commerce. His eventual refusal to work and complete withdrawal from society underscore the psychological toll of such environments.

The narrator, a lawyer, represents the complacency of those who perpetuate these systems. His initial curiosity and pity for Bartleby are tempered by his ultimate inability to bridge the gap between them, reflecting the limitations of empathy in hierarchical relationships.

Ambiguity and Human Connection

One of the novella’s most striking features is its ambiguity. Melville provides little insight into Bartleby’s past, leaving readers to interpret his motivations and the reasons for his decline. This lack of resolution mirrors the narrator’s own frustration and helplessness in understanding Bartleby.

The narrator’s efforts to help Bartleby, though well-intentioned, are ultimately ineffective, highlighting the complexities of human connection. Melville suggests that genuine understanding and compassion require more than superficial gestures—they demand a willingness to confront uncomfortable truths about society and ourselves.

Personal Reflections

Reading Bartleby, the Scrivener was an intellectually stimulating and emotionally challenging experience. Melville’s portrayal of Bartleby’s quiet resistance made me reflect on the ways in which societal structures can stifle individuality and creativity. The story’s exploration of isolation resonated deeply, prompting questions about the nature of empathy and the responsibilities we have toward others.

Conclusion

Bartleby, the Scrivener is a timeless work that explores the tensions between individuality, societal expectations, and human connection. Melville’s nuanced portrayal of Bartleby and his enigmatic resistance continues to captivate readers, making this novella a profound meditation on modern life. For anyone interested in existential questions or critiques of capitalism, this is an essential read.

‘

Works Cited

Melville, Herman. Bartleby, the Scrivener. Putnam’s Monthly Magazine, 1853.